Following a Lahore Excessive Courtroom (LHC) directive to make Justice Baqar Najafi’s report — compiled after a judicial inquiry into the 2014 Mannequin City incident — available for public consumption, the Punjab authorities on Tuesday night released the report by means of the web site of its public relations directorate.
From a studying of the conclusions of Justice Najafi’s report, it’s comprehensible why the provincial authorities fought tooth and nail to stop its launch.
Additionally it is comprehensible why its publication was preceded by a prolonged press convention by Punjab Regulation Minister Rana Sanaullah through which he sought to spotlight the report’s flaws, together with what he referred to as its reliance on “secondary proof” and it, subsequently, having no authorized standing in any way.
He stored referring to it as “faulty”, and the Punjab authorities made positive the Justice Najafi report was accompanied on-line by a one-man committee’s report on a assessment of its flaws.
Delineating the chronology of occasions, Justice Najafi stories that then Punjab Minister for Parliamentary Affairs Rana Sanaullah appears to have already selected June sixteen, 2014 that Pakistan Awami Tehreek (PAT) Chairman Dr Tahirul Qadri wouldn’t be allowed any alternative to carry an extended march from Rawalpindi to Lahore, because the latter deliberate to do on June 23, 2014.
This single-minded willpower of the minister to thwart Dr Qadri’s political aims ended up influencing the police’s heavy-handed strategy in dealing with the situation, which resulted within the useless lack of lives the very subsequent day, Justice Najafi argues within the report.
Although Justice Najafi himself doesn’t affix duty for the tragedy, he invitations readers to assessment the details and circumstances and “simply repair the duty of the unlucky Minhajul Quran incident” themselves.
“The operation deliberate and designed beneath the chairmanship of the
then regulation minister resulted in ugly killings might have simply
“The details and circumstances of the massacre clearly present that the
cops actively participated within the bloodbath.”
“The apathy and recklessness of all authorities in Punjab within the
matter beneath hand created real doubts about their innocence.”
“The actions of police of firing and severely beating the individuals on
the crime scene is irrefutably suggestive that the police did precisely
for which they have been despatched and gathered over there.”
In his report, Justice Najafi recollects that, through the June sixteen assembly, Sanaullah was advised that the PAT was in search of to overthrow the federal government and convey a “revolution”, which Sanaullah made clear that Qadri wouldn’t be allowed to realize.
The commissioner Lahore is then stated to have briefed the minister concerning the obstacles positioned on roads across the PAT-run Minhajul Quran Academy, which have been technically unlawful and might be thought-about and handled as encroachments by the authorities.
Going by Justice Najafi’s account, Sanaullah appears to have seized on this ‘excuse’ to disperse the PAT supporters from Minhajul Quran’s neighborhood.
It was “determined to take away them [the encroachments] with instant impact,” Justice Najafi writes.
“Dr Tauqeer Shah additionally consented on behalf of the Chief Minister, Punjab, [Shahbaz Sharif] for the removing of the obstacles,” he sates, hinting on the potential involvement of the provincial chief government.
The police have been despatched over to take motion. They reached the spot round midnight of June sixteen, 2014 to execute their orders, however “the livid mob and [PAT] sympathisers commenced pelting stones on police”, reads the report.
“The police, as [a] retaliatory measure, resorted to firing in the direction of the protesters, leaving many individuals injured on the website of the incident […] a few of whom succumbed to their accidents afterward,” the report states.
Justice Najafi observes that the “degree of offensive” utilized by police was not “by any stretch of creativeness” commensurate with the resistance provided by the “unarmed PAT staff”.
He additionally regrets the non-cooperation of the police in serving to him dig out the reality. “[…] No police official from prime to backside, whether or not those that actively participated within the operation or not, […] uttered a single phrase concerning the individual underneath whose command the police resorted to firing upon the PAT staff,” he writes.
“Understandably, all [police officials] have been in unison in withholding the knowledge from this tribunal… sadly, such are the information and circumstances underneath which 14 individuals have been shot,” Justice Najafi states.
The decide additionally notes that the order to open hearth should have been given particularly by an officer of the police not under the rank of an Assistant Superintendent or Deputy Superintendent of Police, in line with Part 128 of the Code of Legal Process, 1898.
“The tribunal, subsequently, remained acutely aware of the deliberate silence and concealment of details by police officers/officers […] creating circumstances to assume that the police needed to abide by the command introduced secretly (or brazenly) to realize the goal at the price of even killing the unarmed however valuable residents of Pakistan.”
“This led the tribunal to say that this motif of betrayal of regulation by the police aimed toward burying the reality speaks volumes of their excessive handedness,” he states.
Extra worryingly, Justice Najafi recollects that when the federal authorities was requested why the Punjab police chief and DCO Lahore have been modified within the run-as much as the Mannequin City “massacre”, it didn’t present any passable response. “Such information and circumstances clearly result in an opposed opinion,” his report states.
There’s extra for the informal observer to marvel about: “The day (Jun 17, 2014) and time (between 10.30am to 12pm) each are very very important because the IG Punjab didn’t virtually take over the command of Punjab Police [by then] and on the similar time the honourable new chief justice was about to take oath. Had this tribunal been empowered to research, the hidden fact [regarding the government’s behind-the-scenes machinations] may need been uncovered,” Justice Najafi writes.
Doubts are additionally raised relating to the intentions of Chief Minister Shahbaz Sharif.
“In response to him, having seen the standoff at 9.30am on TV, he instantly contacted his secretary, Dr Tauqir Hussain Shah, on telephone to order the police to disengage forthwith,” recollects Dr Najafi. Nevertheless, he notes, this assertion doesn’t corroborate with what Rana Sanaullah or the Punjab house secretary deposed earlier than him.
“The collected studies from all involved and the affidavits submitted by the cops within the subject don’t depict that any order of ‘disengagement’ by the chief minister, Punjab, was ever conveyed/acquired,” the report states.
“It’s surprising to notice that everybody has intentionally however unsuccessfully tried to cowl one another from potential opposed authorized results.”
“Whereas placing all of the information and the circumstances [together], it has grow to be crystal clear that [the] order for disengagement was not handed in any respect. Slightly, the place taken by CM Punjab seems to be an afterthought protection not taken earlier than the nation within the press convention,” Justice Najafi states.
The report additionally expresses disappointment over the truth that the Punjab authorities didn’t empower the tribunal underneath Part eleven of the Punjab Tribunals Ordinance, 1959.
“The whole gamut of details and circumstances converse volumes that there was no good intention of the [Punjab] authorities to reach at a particular and truthful end result,” it states.
Following the discharge of the Najafi report by the Punjab authorities, Dr Qadri rejected the report whereas speaking to DawnNews, alleging that the report launched by the federal government was a doctored model of the unique.
He stated that the federal government had launched the “doctored” model of the report after he introduced to march in the direction of Civil Secretariat together with his supporters.
The PAT chief claimed that the provincial authorities was hiding the unique model and vowed to convey it to the fore whereas saying to go forward together with his plan to march in the direction of Civil Secretariat.
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *
Sign me up for the newsletter!
The content is the property of the Roznama Urdu and without permission of the publisher will be considered copyright infringement..